CBIC Proposed GST Section 16 Amendments and the Madras HC GST ITC Ruling: What Service Exporters Need to Know

CBIC has proposed changes to Section 16(2) and a new Section 16A so genuine buyers stop losing ITC when their supplier defaults. In the same week, the Madras HC said a supplier later found non-existent isn't enough to deny ITC on its own. Here's what both mean for your ITC and LUT refunds.

November 20, 2026~7 min read

Short answer: The CBIC proposed GST Section 16 amendments would remove the rule that you, as the buyer, must show how your supplier paid the tax on your invoice. They would also add a new Section 16A that denies ITC only where you knowingly took part in fake invoicing. The proposal is not law yet. Trade press says it is aimed at 1 April 2027. Separately, on 10 November 2026 the Madras High Court ruled that ITC can't be denied just because a supplier was later found to be non-existent. The officer has to actually examine your evidence.

Both developments deal with the same problem: genuine buyers losing credit because of someone else's default. For service exporters working under an LUT, that matters because your refund in RFD-01 is only as good as the ITC behind it.

Key facts

  • 8 October 2026: The 57th GST Council meeting in New Delhi deferred the Section 16(2)(c) issue and sent it to an officers' committee. According to Taxscan, the committee has three months to report.
  • 10 November 2026: CBIC's GST Policy Wing issued an Office Memorandum (File No. CBIC-20006/77/2026-GST) proposing changes to Sections 16, 41 and 155 and a new Section 16A. Trade press has reported it, but it isn't published on the CBIC or GST Council websites.
  • 10 November 2026: The Madras HC decided Tvl. Sri Sakthi Enterprises v. State Tax Officer, W.P.(MD) Nos. 31489–31492 of 2026. It set aside four Section 74 orders and sent the matter back for a fresh decision within five months.
  • 30 November 2026: Comments close on CBIC's separate "alternate mechanism" consultation for amending liability and ITC. This is also the Section 16(4) deadline for claiming any missed FY 2025-26 ITC.
  • 1 April 2027: The reported target date for the Section 16 change. Taxscan reports this date. It isn't confirmed in an official document.

What the CBIC proposed GST Section 16 amendments change

Under the current law (as of November 2026), Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act allows ITC only if the tax on your purchase "has been actually paid to the Government, either in cash or through utilisation of input tax credit admissible in respect of the said supply." You can't check that on the portal. GSTR-2B shows that your supplier reported the invoice. It doesn't show whether they paid the tax on it. Courts have split on how strictly to apply the rule. The Gujarat HC in Maruti Enterprise refused to read it down. The Punjab & Haryana HC in Shaurya Alloys (decided 1 October 2026) upheld it but said it must be applied case by case.

Here is the reported before-and-after. The exact draft text hasn't been officially released, so treat the wording below as a summary.

ProvisionCurrent positionProposed (as reported)
Section 16(2)(c)Tax must be actually paid "either in cash or through utilisation of input tax credit admissible in respect of the said supply"Those words removed. The supplier still has to pay, but you no longer have to prove how they paid
Section 16(2)(b)You must have received the goods or servicesYou must have received them "from the said supplier", meaning the same person who issued the invoice (reportedly suggested by Odisha)
New Section 16ANo such provisionITC denied if an investigation shows you knowingly assisted in, took part in, or were a party to invoices issued without actual supply, at any stage of the chain
Section 41Self-assessed ITC credited provisionallyExpressly made subject to the Chapter V conditions
Section 155Burden of proving ITC eligibility is on the claimantUnchanged. The burden stays with you

Two other points are worth noting. The department's power to recover tax from the defaulting supplier stays as it is. And cancellation of a supplier's registration may trigger an inquiry, but on its own it won't be enough to deny your credit. Maharashtra and Karnataka reportedly backed the idea and suggested a way to identify defaulting suppliers.

Is it law yet?

No. The memo went to the GST Council Secretariat so that an agenda note can go before the Standing Committee of Officers. After that it needs a GST Council recommendation and then an amendment to the CGST Act passed by Parliament. That would most likely come through a Finance Bill, but this is our assumption, not something that has been announced. Nothing has been said about retrospective effect. Until it is enacted, the current Section 16(2)(c) applies.

The Madras HC GST ITC ruling in Sri Sakthi Enterprises

The department had denied the buyer's ITC for FY 2022-23, March 2024 and 2024-25 based on an April 2025 inspection, which found the supplier wasn't operating from its declared premises. The Madras HC held that a later finding like this can't, by itself, prove that supplies in earlier periods were fake. The officer must examine what the buyer produced: invoices, e-way bills, bank statements, CA certificates, weighbridge receipts and lorry receipts.

The court did not simply allow the ITC. It sent the case back to the officer, who must pass a reasoned ("speaking") order within five months. This follows earlier Madras HC orders. In Engineering Tools Corp. (W.P. 3505/2024, 15 February 2024), the court held that ITC can't be rejected only because the supplier's registration was cancelled retrospectively. Another order reported on 16 November 2026 held that no interest is payable on ineligible ITC that was never used. You can search the order by case number on the Madras High Court judgments portal. Taxscan's report also covers it.

Why this matters if you export services under LUT

When you export services under an LUT (filed in RFD-11), you charge no IGST. Your ITC on domestic purchases (coworking rent, CA fees, subcontractors, phone and internet, Indian software subscriptions) then builds up in your electronic credit ledger. To get it back, you file RFD-01 for refund of unutilised ITC under Section 54(3), using the Rule 89(4) formula. If you're new to this, our guide to GST on export of services covers the basics, and FIRA vs EDF vs LUT explains which document does what.

Refund applications are where ITC gets examined most closely. If a vendor didn't pay its tax, or its registration was later cancelled, the officer can cut the "Net ITC" in your formula. That usually starts with a show cause notice in RFD-08.

Worked example

Say your agency's quarter looks like this:

  • Net ITC (inputs and input services, not capital goods): ₹1.8 lakh
  • Turnover of zero-rated supply of services: ₹30 lakh
  • Adjusted total turnover: ₹32 lakh

Refund = (₹30 lakh × ₹1.8 lakh) ÷ ₹32 lakh = ₹1,68,750.

Now suppose ₹40,000 of that ITC came from a subcontractor whose registration was cancelled retrospectively, and the officer disallows it. Net ITC falls to ₹1.4 lakh and your refund drops to ₹1,31,250. That's ₹37,500 lost over one vendor you had no control over.

How each change would affect you

  • 16(2)(c) wording removed: This helps you. Officers could no longer reject refund ITC because you can't prove how the vendor discharged its tax. The vendor would still have to pay, though, so a vendor who never paid at all may still be a problem. How far the relief goes will depend on the final text.
  • "From the said supplier" in 16(2)(b): This matters for agencies that route work through intermediaries. If one freelancer does the work but a different entity bills you, expect questions. Make sure the invoice comes from the party that actually delivered the service, or that your contract clearly shows why it doesn't.
  • Section 16A "knowingly": For a genuine freelancer or agency this should rarely bite. But because Section 155 keeps the burden of proof on you, your records are your defence.
  • Madras HC ruling: If your refund is cut because a vendor was later found missing, you can cite Sri Sakthi Enterprises and Engineering Tools in your reply to the RFD-08. Ask the officer to deal with your evidence in a speaking order. Remember that Madras HC rulings bind authorities in Tamil Nadu. Elsewhere they are persuasive, not binding.

What evidence works for services

The Madras HC's list (e-way bills, weighbridge and lorry receipts) is built for goods. Services leave no trail of trucks, so collect these instead for every domestic vendor whose ITC you claim:

  • A signed contract, statement of work or purchase order naming the vendor's legal name and GSTIN
  • Proof of delivery: emails, files, timesheets, tickets, access logs, coworking entry records
  • Payment by bank transfer to the vendor's own account (no cash, no third-party accounts)
  • The invoice showing in your GSTR-2B, accepted in IMS, with a screenshot saved each month
  • A check of the vendor's GSTIN status before you pay. Our GSTIN search guide shows how
  • For large refunds, a CA certificate tying your ITC to your books

Dates to act on now

  • 30 November 2026: This is the last date under Section 16(4) to claim any FY 2025-26 ITC you missed, or the date you file your FY 2025-26 annual return if that comes earlier. The proposed amendments don't extend this.
  • 30 November 2026: Comments close on CBIC's alternate mechanism consultation on MyGov. It would move corrections to GSTR-1, GSTR-1A or IFF and IMS from the April 2027 return period. It is a separate proposal from Section 16. We covered other recent return changes in GST changes from 1 November for exporters.
  • Refund time limit: RFD-01 must generally be filed within two years of the relevant date. For services exported, that is usually the date you receive payment in foreign exchange. Don't hold back a refund waiting for the amendment.
  • Early 2027: Watch for the officers' committee report and the next GST Council meeting. The GST Council website and the CBIC tax information portal are where the official text will appear.

Disclaimer: The CBIC memo hasn't been officially published, and the details above are based on trade-press summaries of it. The 1 April 2027 date is reported, not confirmed. Before you rely on any of this in a refund reply or a notice, confirm the position with your GST practitioner or jurisdictional officer. For more compliance guides for Indian service exporters, start at our homepage.

Frequently asked questions

Are the CBIC proposed GST Section 16 amendments in force?

No. They come from a CBIC Office Memorandum dated 10 November 2026 that has gone to the GST Council Secretariat for the Standing Committee of Officers. They still need a GST Council recommendation and an amendment to the CGST Act passed by Parliament. Until then, the current Section 16(2)(c) applies, including the requirement that the supplier has actually paid the tax.

From when would the Section 16 changes apply, and will they be retrospective?

Taxscan reports a target date of 1 April 2027, but no official document confirming that date has been published. Nothing has been said about retrospective effect either. Assume your existing ITC claims and pending refunds will be judged under the current law, and keep your documents ready on that basis.

What did the Madras HC decide in Sri Sakthi Enterprises?

In W.P.(MD) Nos. 31489–31492 of 2026, decided on 10 November 2026, the Madras High Court set aside four Section 74 orders. It held that an April 2025 finding that the supplier was non-existent could not, by itself, prove that earlier supplies were fake. The officer must examine the buyer's evidence and pass a reasoned order within five months.

Can my LUT refund be cut if my vendor didn't pay GST?

Yes, under the current Section 16(2)(c) the officer can reduce the Net ITC in your Rule 89(4) refund calculation, usually by first issuing an RFD-08 notice. Reply with your contracts, proof of delivery, bank payments and GSTR-2B records. Cite relevant court rulings and ask for a speaking order that deals with your evidence.

Does the new Section 16A affect genuine freelancers and agencies?

It is aimed at people who knowingly take part in fake invoicing, so it should rarely affect genuine service exporters. However, Section 155 keeps the burden of proving ITC eligibility on you. Pay vendors by bank transfer, keep signed contracts and proof that work was delivered, and check each vendor's GSTIN status before you claim credit.

Is the alternate mechanism consultation the same as the Section 16 proposal?

No. CBIC opened the alternate mechanism consultation on 1 November 2026. It proposes that corrections to tax liability and ITC go through GSTR-1, GSTR-1A or IFF and the Invoice Management System instead of GSTR-3B edits, from the April 2027 return period. Comments close on 30 November 2026 on MyGov. The Section 16 proposal is a separate exercise.